Jurors
Not listed
Best Novel
| Winner | Title | Author(s) | Carnivorous Lunar Activities | Max Booth III |
| Killer Lake | W.D. Gagliani & David Benton | |
| ★ | Lakehouse Infernal | Christine Morgan |
| Merciless | Bryan Smith | |
| Reception | Kenzie Jennings | |
| They Kill | Tim Waggoner | |
| Toxic Love | Kristopher Triana |
Best Novella
| Winner | Title | Author(s) | How Much To..? | Matt Shaw |
| ★ | One For the Road | Wesley Southard |
| Paradise, Maine | Jackson R. Thomas | |
| Saint Sadist | Lucas Mangum | |
| Weeping Season | Seán O’Connor | |
| White Trash Gothic Part Two | Edward Lee |
Best Short Story
| Winner | Title | Author(s) | ★ | Angelbait (The Big Book of Blasphemy) |
Ryan Harding |
| Breaking the Waters (Pseudopod 9/19) |
Donyae Coles | |
| Censered (And Hell Followed) |
Christine Morgan | |
| Norwegian Woods (The Big Book of Blasphemy) |
Jeremy Wagner | |
| Param (Trigger Warning: Body Horror) |
Susan Snyder | |
| Shoulder Pain (The Macabre Museum 10/19) |
Chandler Morrison |
Best Collection
| Winner | Title | Author(s) | Dawn of the Living Impaired, and Other Messed-Up Zombie Stories | Christine Morgan |
| Dead Sea Chronicles | Tim Curran | |
| ★ | Dirty Rotten Hippies and Other Stories | Bryan Smith |
| Resisting Madness | Wesley Southard | |
| This Is a Horror Book | Charles Austin Muir | |
| Various States of Decay | Matt Hayward |
Best Anthology
| Winner | Title | Editor(s) | ★ | And Hell Followed | Jarod Barbee & Patrick C. Harrison III |
| Dig Two Graves | Jarod Barbee & Patrick C. Harrison III | |
| Midnight In The Graveyard | Kenneth W. Cain | |
| Polish Extreme | Edward Lee & Karolina Kaczkowska | |
| The Big Book of Blasphemy | Regina Mitchell & David G. Barnett | |
| The New Flesh: A Literary Tribute to David Cronenberg | Sam Richard & Brendan Vidito |