Jurors
Not listed
Best Novel
| Winner | Title | Author(s) | Dust | Chris Miller |
| Gone to See the River Man | Kristopher Triana | |
| Pandemonium | Ryan Harding & Lucas Mangum | |
| Slaughter Box | Carver Pike | |
| ★ | The Magpie Coffin | Wile E. Young |
| They All Died Screaming | Kristopher Triana | |
| Tome | Ross Jeffery |
Best Novella
| Winner | Title | Author(s) | Bella’s Boys | Thomas R Clark |
| How Much 2 | Matt Shaw | |
| Juniper | Ross Jeffery | |
| Red Station | Kenzie Jennings | |
| The Night Silver River Run Red | Christine Morgan | |
| The Slob | Aron Beauregard | |
| ★ | True Crime | Samantha Kolesnik |
Best Short Story
| Winner | Title | Author(s) | Footsteps (Diabolica Britannica) |
Janine Pipe |
| Full Moon Shindig (Visceral: Collected Flesh) |
Patrick C. Harrison III | |
| ★ | My Body (Midnight in the Pentagram) |
Wesley Southard |
| Next in Line (Devour the Earth) |
Susan Snyder | |
| Phylum (The Comfort Zone and Other Safe Spaces) |
Tom Over | |
| The God in the Hills | Jon Steffens | |
| The Incident at Barrow Farm (Cerberus Rising) |
M Ennenbach |
Best Collection
| Winner | Title | Author(s) | Blood Relations | Kristopher Triana |
| Cerberus Rising, M Ennenbach | Chris Miller & Patrick C. Harrison III | |
| Rhapsody in Red | Peter Molnar | |
| The Comfort Zone and Other Safe Spaces | Tom Over | |
| ★ | The Essential Sick Stuff | Ronald Kelly |
| Visceral: Collected Flesh | Christine Morgan & Patrick C. Harrison III | |
| War of Dictates | John Baltisberger |
Best Anthology
| Winner | Title | Editor(s) | Brewtality | K. Trap Jones |
| Chew on This! | Robert Essig | |
| Crash Code | Q. Parker | |
| If I Die Before I Wake Vol. 3: Tales of Deadly Women and Retribution | R.E. Sargent & Steven Pajak | |
| Psi-Wars: Classified Cases of Psychic Phenomena | Joshua Viola | |
| Welcome to the Splatter Club | K. Trap Jones | |
| ★ | Worst Laid Plans | Samantha Kolesnik |